AI·User questions whether to withdraw from ACL ARR and resubmit to a workshop after mediocre 2.5-3 scores on an Interpretability-track EMNLP paper.
Search
What are you looking for?
4 results for “acl”
Even after getting ARR reviews and a meta review, how is the acceptance decided at the *ACL venues, because I have seen meta review 3.5 getting to findings and 3 getting to main or even getting rejected. Then what is the purpose of the overall score and recommendation? What do the conferences see when deciding? Do they only care about the metareview and their comments, or the whole set of reviews…
We submitted our first paper to ARR, intending to commit to IJCNLP-AACL. Area: Multilingualism and Cross-Lingual NLP Scores: (3,4) (2.5,3) (3,3) - average 2.83 for reviews, 3.33 for confidence 3 for soundness on all, 4 for reproducibility, and 2,3,3 for excitement. The reviewer who gave us 2.5 has a very short review. They only list one weakness in two sentences and give the paper 2.5. They also …
Reviews are released. Lets discuss scores here. submitted by /u/Historical_Pause247 [link] [comments]